Rubric scoring guide examples. Part A: Graphic Organizer – Rubric.

Contribute to the Help Center

Submit translations, corrections, and suggestions on GitHub, or reach out on our Community forums.

4. Sample rubric demonstrating the key elements of a rubric. In-depth plan organizes information. The rater matches an entire piece of student work to a single description on the scale. Heidi Goodrich Andrade, a rubrics expert, defines a rubric as "a scoring tool that lists the criteria for a piece of work or 'what counts. Additionally there are several free (though generally registration is required) on-line generators for rubric creation including iRubric and Rubistar . In a holistic rubric, the entire performance is evaluated and This State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR®) constructed-response scoring guide provides student exemplars at all score points for extended constructed-response and short constructed-response prompts from the STAAR reading language arts grade 4 operational test. Holistic Rubric: This is the type of rubric that is much easier to create, but much more difficult to use accurately. cted and what will be assessed. Note that there are two versions of the Official Scoring Guide to be used depending on writing purpose: one for narrative From comparing the two styles of assessment, you can summarize the difference in a scoring guide and a rubric in the following way: scoring guides assess quantity while rubrics assess quality. Score scale: This might be a quantity system (usually 1 to 4) or phrases like “exceeds expectations, meets expectations, under expectations,” and 6 points. College Board’s APUSH DBQ rubric recommends that you spend 15 minutes reading the documents and 45 minutes writing the essay . Scoring guide; Standard evaluations; Student teaching portfolios; Teachers; Writing assignment grading; These are just some examples of how and where you can use such templates. 0 The response… Score of 1 Report on Existing Knowledge of 2 on Existing Knowledge with Simplistic Use of a Research Method Score of 3 Ineffectual Argument for a New Understanding f 4 Well-Supported, Articulate Conveying New Understanding f 5 Rich Analysis of a New Understanding Addressing a Gap in the Research Base AP Research Through-Course Performance Task—100% of AP Research Score; Component Scoring Method Weight; Academic Paper (4,000–5,000 words) College Board scored: 75%: Presentation and Oral Defense (15–20 minutes total for both the presentation and 3–4 questions from a panel of 3 evaluators that follows). Oct 20, 2022 · The guides include rubrics and real examples of student responses for short and extended constructed response items. Rubrics allow for quicker and more consistent marking. At least 25 percent of student responses for each grade/subject and course are then routed to trained human General Scoring Notes • When applying the rubric for each individual row, you should award the score for that row based solely upon the criteria indicated for that row, according to the preponderance of evidence. The writing attempts to connect with the audience in an earnest, pleasing, but impersonal manner. Teacher scored: 25% Criteria Total Points Interview Questions 80 Poise (comfortable, composed, confident, eye contact) 5 Ability to communicate (clarity of thought, articulation, and engaging to panel) 5 Project plan leverages or contributes to existing infrastructure or precedents. Organization. 5m; 7g weight a distance of 0. May 7, 2024 · Example task: Design and build a trebuchet that is adjustable to launch a . NOTE: To receive the highest performance level presumes that the student also achieved the preceding performance levels in that row. Also consult with your Table Leader about exam booklets that seem to have no response or a response that is unrelated to the question. Expresses specific career goals related to their major, and provides evidence of extensive, meaningful, and career‐specific actions taken, beyond coursework (e. Aug 20, 2015 · I typically provide students with a printed copy of the rubric when we are in the beginning stages of working on a big assignment like this, along with a prompt that describes the task itself. A rubric has three essential features: evaluative criteria, quality definitions, and a scoring strategy. Do not use any of these scoring guides, PFAs, DFAs, or performance task rubrics when administering the summative assessments. There are two types of rubrics: holistic and analytical. A well-defined rubric will make marking of reflection systematic and support both you and the reflectors. , a presentation, essay, group project), the skills they are being tested on (e. It lists criteria and describes levels of quality […] Rubric Examples* Writing Rubric (Johnson Community College) 2 Subject A Scoring Guide (University of CA) 3 Scoring Guide for Writing (CA State University, Fresno) 4 Scoring Guide for Integrative Science (CA State University, Fresno) 5 Writing Rubric (Northeastern Illinois University) 6 Oral Presentation Holistic Scoring Rubric (SE Missouri The applicant’s name and the wording “Personal Statement” at the top of the page. Spelling and grammar. 2 While the items contained in this scoring guide are all 2 -point short text items, the total number of points for a short-text item can vary from 1 point to 4 points. • Read the whole report before assigning a score for any row. The process for the hybrid scoring model is outlined below. You could even look at an example together and have students practice using the rubric to assess that example. Below you’ll find a range of free, customizable rubric templates for business and academic use. The best way to get your time management down is practice. Effectively articulates the relationship between the IT infrastructure and organizational goals; Has experience in strategic planning to set vision, goals, and objectives for a complex system; Demonstrates an understanding of the management practices needed to guide staff, partners, and These resources support the practice and training tests for the CAASPP and ELPAC. Jun 16, 2023 · A rubric typically has three elements: Efficiency standards: These are the assorted facets on which the task can be evaluated. Rubrics are typically comprised of rows and columns. Rubrics can be used for a wide array of assignments: papers, projects, oral presentations, artistic performances, group projects, etc. Creating a rubric takes time and requires thought and experimentation. Rubrics are a valuable tool to speed up grading and clarify expectations. For each exemplar in the document, the descriptors identified from the rubric are the best representation for that exemplar. See example from 11. Major Types of Rubrics. A rubric is an assessment tool that clearly indicates achievement criteria across all the components of any kind of student work, from written to oral to visual. The three response is proficient and demonstrates a complete understanding of the texts and task. 3–5 Reading Language Arts Constructed Response Scoring Guide. 1) Read the rubric as a whole before looking at each criterion in more detail. 1 point – No clear organization to the presentation. For example, it gives the concrete example of a study done by Dr. STAMPe. It has three parts: 1) performance criteria; 2) rating scale; and 3) indicators. Go through the rubric when introducing the assignment. A rubric is a type of scoring guide that assesses and articulates specific components and expectations for an assignment. critical thinking, written communication, teamwork), personal and social responsibility (i. Item. Sources of Evidence • Assessment Plan • Design for Instruction Assessment Indicators and Questions 1. Columns are used to define levels of performance for each criterion. For example, a very basic rubric might be: Scoring Guide for Subject Matter Expertise Accomplished A comprehensive grasp of the subject matter is demonstrated included, but not limited to, an in-depth understand of the relevant concepts, theories, and issues related to the topic. Step 1: Re-examine the learning objectives to be addressed by the task. Rubrics can be set up as non-scoring rubrics, which allows for Rubric Examples. It can be used for marking assignments, class participation, or overall grades. (1 point) Response is an evidence-based explanation of how the table supports two A rubric describes the criteria that will be used to evaluate a specific task, such as a student writing assignment, poster, oral presentation, or other project. An interview scoring sheet, also known as an interview scorecard or score sheet, is a tool that interviewers use to score a candidate’s qualifications for a position. This page provides access to each released essay item, constructed-response item, open-response item, and writing prompt included on the MCAS tests from 2018 to 2024 (except 2020); the scoring guide that accompanies each item; and samples of student work at each score point for the item. Rubrics without carefully determined and relative grade weights can often produce a final score that does not align with the instructor’s expectations for the score. Analytic scoring rubrics Analytic rubrics attempt to break down the final product or goal into measurable Examples. Design appears scalable or replicable. Official Scoring Guides (Essential Skills) * The Official Writing Scoring Guide is the only one allowable rubric for the use of scoring writing Work Samples to demonstrate proficiency in the Essential Skill of Writing. Whether for online or face-to-face courses VCF SCHOLARSHIP APPLICATION SCORING RUBRICS . to guide long range plans, policies and programs. The rubrics below are designed as guidelines and do not address all possible aspects of essay and recommendation characteristics. 1. List the most relevant objectives of the assignment. The calendar includes dates when educators can expect to see Jul 3, 2019 · The scoring rubrics for the ACT and SAT are designed this way, although when students take them, they will receive a holistic score. 3 The writer seems sincere, but not fully engaged or involved. Assessment. [1] In simpler terms, it serves as a set of criteria for grading assignments. Evidence-Based argument essay (1 long essay); suggested time: 90 minutes. Gives you a picture of the student. 2018 Rubric v1. It shows substantial depth, fullness, and complexity of thought. This assessment is designed to assess the progress that emergent bilingual (EB) students make in learning the English language. Advantages of Using Rubrics The scoring rubric is meant to provide a consistent measure against which to evaluate recitations. 2: A partially inadequate answer that does not demonstrate the required competence. The conclusion restates the thesis or offers a com-ment or question on it. Rubrics are systematic scoring methods that use pre-determined criteria. Score Point 1. Hiring managers use score sheets to ensure a company evaluates candidates in a fair, consistent manner and that interviewers rate each candidate using an objective measurement Grade 10 Literacy Assessment. (0, 2, 4 or 6 points) Decision Rules and Scoring Notes. '. Varied or subtle transition sound natural, enhance the flow of the paper. 2 points – Somewhat organized, but loses focus 3 or more times. Essentially, a rubric divides an assessment into smaller parts (criteria) and then provides details for different levels of performance possible for each part (Stevens and Levi 2013). Weight. About the Sample Test Scoring Guide. The report is both accurate and com-pelling. This example helps the reader understand that there may be negative consequences to eliminating the penny. g. provides evidence and draws conclusions from the texts. There are two main types of rubrics - holistic and analytic, although Nitko (2001) includes a third type, the annotated, holistic rubric. Example 2: Advanced Seminar This rubric is designed for assessing discussion performance in an advanced undergraduate or graduate seminar. This allows you to match your scoring guide with your objectives and actual instruction. Scores in Level 1 and Level 2 represent not-yet-accomplished teaching practice. 4 points – Incorporates relevant course concepts into presentation where appropriate. The writing has discernable purpose, but is not compelling. 5g weight a distance of 0. Scoring Method. Represents a worthy contribution. Section Benchmark Levels. These examples of work sample tasks are aligned to the 2011-12 Mathematics Problem Solving Scoring Guide and to the Common Core State Standards (CCSS). " For example, a rubric for an essay might tell students that their work will be judged on purpose With a holistic rubric the rater assigns a single score (usually on a 1 to 4 or 1 to 6 point scale) based on an overall judgment of the student work. Feb 8, 2019 · Click the following link to download the checklist: Analytic Rubric Checklist Examples of Exemplary Rubrics. Rubrics allow instructors to communicate expectations to students, allow students to check in on their progress mid-assignment, and can increase the reliability of scores. Here you can see the steps used to create two kinds of rubric: one for problems in a physics exam for a small, upper-division physics course, and another for an essay assignment in a large, lower-division sociology course. Holistic rubrics are useful when only one attribute is being evaluated, as they detail different levels of performance within a single A rubric defines in writing what is expected of the student to get a particular grade on an assignment. This style of rubric enables a single, overall assessment/evaluation of a learner’s performance on a task. Rubric: (2 points) Response is an evidence-based explanation of how the table supports two other sources with two pieces of evidence from different sources and that explains how each example supports the idea. We celebrate and It can be difficult to have consistency across scores, and holistic scoring guides are most helpful when making decisions quickly rather than providing detailed feedback to students. It is not intended to be comprehensive but serves as a companion to the evaluation criteria. Guide to Developing Rubrics for Assessment 3 | P a g e 3. Criteria 5 4 3 2 1 Purpose and Voice The writer’s voice is Jun 28, 2024 · Grade 6 and Below. Provide examples. The kind of rubric that is most appropriate will depend on the assignment in question. 2022–23 Calendar of Events and New Reporting Structure An updated 2022–23 Calendar of Events is now posted in the District and Campus Coordinator Resources (DCCR). This is appropriate for an undergraduate-level course (Carnegie Mellon). , writing, comprehension, presentation, collaboration), and the goal of the assessment for instructors (e. SAMPLE B RUBRICS AND SCORING GUIDE. Reading, Listening sections: 1-6* Writing, Speaking sections: 1-8. ADDITIONAL SCORES: In addition to the scores represented on the rubric, teachers can also assign scores of 0 (zero). For access to all released MCAS test questions, visit the Released Test Questions and Practice Tests page. The evaluative criteria defined by a scoring Keep rubrics clear, concise, and aligned with learning outcomes. Your score should reflect your judgment of the Aug 24, 2021 · The grade 10 English Language Arts (ELA) legacy composition rubrics for the retests are located here: Scoring Guides for ELA Legacy Composition. This helps to quantify the evaluation process and make it more objective. Ten to twelve. Examples of Rubric Creation. The Association of American Colleges and Universities created a series of high-quality rubrics entitled VALUE rubrics that span intellectual and practical skills (i. A blank rubric template is a very useful tool which can make your life easier. All student responses are scored for the first time by the ASE. This can be extremely helpful in reflection, which can feel as if it needs to be assessed by instinct alone. They need to align with the specified studying outcomes for the task. There are likely many aims you have for the assignment (presentation, correctness Sample Holistic Scoring Guide. civic engagement, global Apr 10, 2018 · these when preparing their application to ensure they receive the highest score possible. Key Words: Rubric, scoring guide, iRubric, expectations, scores, online, gradebook Introduction Assessment Plan Scoring Guide Standard The teacher uses multiple assessment modes and approaches aligned with learning goals to assess student learning before, during, and after instruction. 75m; Example rubric: Holistic rubric. , an internship), to help criteria rating s. By building student voice and agency, and through utilizing a set of coherent instructional Rubrics are used to measure student learning for scoring and grading. An analytic rubric would assess the GPA, references, and essay using distinct scales and criteria. This system will also enable teachers to review their curriculum and find gaps. Understand and Analyze Context. Aug 30, 2018 · Often found in the education sector, a rubric is a tool for scoring performance based on specific criteria. extracts and clearly communicates relevant information from texts and summarizes ideas. SAMPLE A RUBRICS AND SCORING GUIDE. Clearly state the purpose of the assessment, which topic(s) learners are being tested on, the type of assessment (e. Within this guide, each item is presented with the following information: Item number. ale indicatorsWhat is a rubric?A rubric is a scoring guide used to evaluate perf. A score of. This guide will explain writing rubrics, their benefits, and how to create and use them effectively. Rubrics are criterion-referenced grading tools that describe qualitative differences in student performance for evaluating and scoring assessments. The Texas English Language Proficiency Assessment System (TELPAS) is an English language proficiency assessment aligned to the Texas English Language Proficiency Standards (ELPS). As used today, the term rubric refers to a scoring guide used to evaluate the quality of students' constructed responses—for example, their written compositions, oral presentations, or science projects. Criterion-referenced grading refers to students being evaluated based on their performance against a set of criteria. Interview Guide and Scoring Rubric ABOUT Queen City Certified sets the standard for gender equity in the US workplace. A sample scoring guide is available in Appendix G of this document. Sample writing iRubrics are used for illustration. 4 (Exemplary) 3 (Proficient) 2 (Acceptable) 1 (Emerging) 0 (Insufficient) Success Potential. For example, a candidate receiving a Superior level for a factor with a weight of 2 would receive 10 points for that rating factor (5 X 2 =10). Rubrics help instructors assess student work more objectively and consistently. AP® Research — Presentation and Oral Defense 2021 Scoring Guidelines. If they seem inappropriate for a specific essay, ask your Table Leader for assistance. Types of scoring rubrics Despite the overwhelming number of scoring rubrics you can find on the Internet and in various textbooks and curriculum guides, most rubrics fall into one of two categories: Analytic or holistic scoring rubrics. The rubric, Judge’s Guide, and Analytic rubrics can be created in Excel (and information can easily be aggregated and numerically summarized), with Word's table function, or even just sketched out on a pad of paper. Define rubric criteria Rubric (academic) In the realm of US education, a rubric is a "scoring guide used to evaluate the quality of students' constructed responses" according to James Popham. The prompts are presented as they appeared on the test, and responses were scored Decide what you want to grade for this assignment or activity. The writer seems aware of a purpose, and attempts to select content and structures that reflect it. The scoring guide provides two student writing samples that illustrate each performance level outlined in the rubric. To ensure that both students and graders have a clear understanding of the rubric, it can be helpful to provide examples of short answer responses at each To look at the scores and read the commentary, click on the "Scores/Commentary" link below the Student Sample being viewed. Feb 22, 2020 · Assessment rubrics. Set timers during your APUSH DBQ practice test so you can get a feel for how much time it takes to put an answer together. guide, as they are relative to specific grade levels (end of grades 3, 5, 8). Communicate rubric expectations to students. DOWNLOAD THE 22-23 RUBRICS. Excellent (3 points) Good (2 points) Poor (1 point) Number of sources. For you and your students, the rubric defines what is ex. Browse our rubric examples for subjects like art, social studies, and math, as well as skills like A score of 2. * STAMPe test takers can achieve 6+ (Pre-Advanced) benchmark level for Reading and Listening Sections. 6. The essay demonstrates superior control of Jul 10, 2023 · Here’s an example of what your scoring system might look like: 1: A completely insufficient answer that indicates a lack of competence. Alignment with Learning Goals and Instruction Grade 10 Graduation Literacy Assessment. What Is a Writing Rubric? A writing rubric is a scoring guide used to evaluate written work. Use of rubrics in higher education Rubric is a scoring tool or guide which specifies a coherent set of important criteria for evaluating student work and includes descriptions of different levels of performance, or mastery, for each of the criteria. A rubric is an assessment tool that provides information on performance expectations for students. IMPORTANT: A Level 3 or Level 4 performance is not required for each component and constructed response item. Component. The body fully explores the topic and presents information in a sensible order. Student cites the source for each example. A Rubric is an assessment tool for communicating expectations of quality. All constructed-response questions for the Spanish language version of STAAR are scored using only human scorers. Review and revise rubrics periodically to ensure relevance and accuracy. Rubrics can be used as scoring or grading guides, to provide formative feedback to support and guide ongoing learning efforts, or both. This State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR®) constructed-response scoring guide provides student exemplars at all score points for extended constructed-response and short constructed-response prompts from the STAAR English I operational test. Here is a sample of a rubric with a range of points within each performance level. STAMP for Hebrew (Grade Band 2-6) Reading, Listening sections: 1-9 Writing, Speaking sections: 1-8. Aug 19, 2020 · For example, a holistic rubric might ask reviewers to assign a score of 1-4 for the application as a whole (where a Level 1 application includes a high GPA, excellent references, and an outstanding essay). There are two major categories of rubrics: Holistic: In this type of rubric, a single score is provided based on raters’ overall perception of the quality of the performance. No items or student work samples are released from the retests. Keep these objectives specific and clear. A rubric is a means of scoring a performance assessment wherein multiple criteria are being assessed and quality of performance or product is important. 3: A satisfactory answer that indicates the minimum requirements are met. Row 1. • Reward the student for skills they have demonstrated. . The writer states the central idea is (“to show what the bulk ways of transportation then and now”). Jun 7, 2024 · MCAS Student Work/Scoring Guides. However, businesses also use a rubric to measure things like employee performance and to evaluate the success of a project or product. Reasons, details, facts strongly support topic. This sample rubric is for an Assistant Director level position in marketing and communications. 300–400-word limit. Rubrics can be used for a variety of assignments: research papers, group projects, portfolios, and presentations. It makes clear the significance to a larger context. The prompts are presented as they appeared on the test, and To test this theory a survey of high school math students was conducted and the following results were obtained: 48% complete math homework regularly. (1 point) Source #2 adds to the reader’s understanding by providing more information about why some people think the penny should be eliminated. Part I: Short Essay Questions Each short essay question will be scored separately, and assigned a score of 5,4,3,2, or 1 in each of the 5 categories in the scoring guide shown below. Essay (20pts) Based on the following: Applicants address the “Essay Topic” for the specific scholarship for which they are applying (400 – 500-word limit). The Arizona’s Academic Standards Assessment (AASA) Sample Test Scoring Guides provide details about the items, student response types, correct responses, and related scoring considerations for AASA Sample Test items. Step 4: Create a format for the rubric. Whaples which The table below illustrates a simple grading rubric with each of the four elements for a history research paper. The response demonstrates clear, focused, unified, and coherent organization and is fully developed and detailed. Strong topic sentences/thesis statement addresses the prompt /topic in a compelling and highly interesting way. There are two main types of rubrics: Analytic Rubric: An analytic rubric specifies at least two characteristics to be assessed at each performance level and provides a separate score for Writing rubrics are essential tools for teachers. Rubric. To administer or find other information about practice or training tests, visit the Practice and Training Tests web page. Applications are scored on a 3300 point scale. This central idea claim is not valid because the statement about the article is unclear and irrelevant. Because rubrics are used to assess This article shows how rubrics can be created for writing courses in English as a foreign language by teachers and students using the iRubric tool of Rcampus. 2. Please review the scholarship reviewer rubric below to help you in crafting your application responses. Rubrics can improve both teaching and learning. Project isolated from related work and duplicates effort. Part A: Graphic Organizer – Rubric. Understanding and analyzing an argument (3 short-answer questions); suggested time: 30 minutes. 5m; 10g weight a distance of 0. Typically presented in table format, rubrics contain evaluative criteria, quality definitions for To determine an applicant's score for each rating factor, multiply the weight indicated for each factor by the points (5, 3, or 1) for the benchmark level you assigned. Rows are used to define the various criteria being used to assess an assignment. In the scoring guide, assign point values or score ranges for each performance level. 75 is the lowest rubric score in the range of clear evidence of accomplished teaching practice. Developing Rubrics & Scoring Guides. College Board scored. TELPAS fulfills ESSA requirements for These scoring guidelines will be useful for most of the essays that you read. Example task: When instructors give out an assignment, many will provide you with a detailed grading rubric to further your understanding of how it will be evaluated. ) Content: currency & relevance. 3 points – Incorporates several course Before reviewing applications for a position or conducting an interview, it is important to create a scoring rubric that identifies what you are looking for in a candidate. 40% do not complete math homework regularly AND have less than a B average in math class. Why use rubrics? Rubrics help instructors: Assess assignments consistently from student-to-student. Step 4: Score Samples. Competent A thorough grasp of the subject matter is demonstrated Example 1: Discussion Class This rubric assesses the quality of student contributions to class discussions. We can then conclude that scoring guides are teacher-centered (prioritizing efficiency of grading over meaningful feedback), while rubrics are student Mar 4, 2024 · A rubric is an assessment tool often shaped like a matrix, which describes levels of achievement in a specific area of performance, understanding, or behavior. Typically, a teacher provides a series of letter grades or a range of numbers (1-4 or 1-6, for Rubrics usually consist of a table, grid, or matrix. Taken together, the Rubric Scoring Guide for Paragraph, Report, and Essay Writing. Scoring rubrics include evaluative criteria with performance descriptors and are either applied collectively as a holistic score or individually as an analytic score (Popham, 2017). 229 advanced writing seminar. , gauging formative or summative understanding of the topic). The steps will be summarized and discussed, followed by presentations of two sample scoring rubrics. CPHHS scoring rubric for undergraduate scholarships. MAX POINTS MAX POINTS DESCRIPTION 1000 . Rubric and Elaborations ! Note: All rationales correspond to the revised rubric snapshot shown above. Criteria. e. 3. Expand All. We suggest you review it before the competition to get a sense of what you should look for in individual performances. Before jumping into creating a rubric, think carefully about the performance objectives of the assignment. End-of-Course Exam (2 Hours)—45% of AP Seminar Score. Rubrics are often used to evaluate student work based on predetermined criteria. If you’re a teacher and you haven’t even tried using such template, you should Oct 1, 1997 · The Rudiments of Rubrics. The common rubrics are one element of UPCHS’s approach, which puts its diverse population into an all-honors or AP curriculum, regardless of past educational achievement. The rubric is used for holistic scoring of all extensive constructed response questions. 30% of 45%. The report situates the student’s investigation of the complexities of a problem or issue in research that draws upon a wide variety of appropriate sources. 55% have a B average or better in math class. Project plan overlooks or fails to mention important connections to relevant work by others, but redeemable. rmance, a product, or a project. Essay #1 - Educational and Career Goals 700 Content Rubric Examples* Writing Rubric (Johnson Community College) Subject A Scoring Guide (University of CA) Scoring Guide for Writing (CA State University, Fresno) Scoring Guide for Integrative Science (CA State University, Fresno) Writing Rubric (Northeastern lllinois University) Oral Presentation Holistic Scoring Rubric (SE Missouri State U) Sep 15, 2022 · Introduction to Rubrics. 3 points – Mostly organized, but loses focus once or twice. We help employers build gender-equitable organizations where people not only want to work, but can thrive, using data-informed best practices, collaborative learning experiences, and ongoing support. Another powerful step that makes the rubric even more effective is to score sample products as a class, using the rubric as a guide. The writing begins with an inter-esting or provocative introduction that contains a clear and concise thesis state-ment. The complete set of mathematics general rubrics for scoring short-text items is included in Appendix A. AA superior response addresses the question fully and explores the issues thoughtfully. kd hp yy gz rp xl db vf kb ip